Monday, June 20, 2011

Fw: [KOLKATA UNPLUGGED] Oh no, Mother!

THE EMINENT THAT SHALL FOLLOW.
ANOTHER LESSON.

Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------


From: "Anirban Chaudhuri" <notification+i33imkim@facebookmail.com>
Date: Mon, 20 Jun 2011 06:27:15 -0700
To: KOLKATA UNPLUGGED<kolkataclassic@groups.facebook.com>
ReplyTo: Reply to Comment <g+40zynda000000s37hzv02rxz2mpwm3i00001fo3ly391t746@groups.facebook.com>
Subject: Re: [KOLKATA UNPLUGGED] Oh no, Mother!

@Suman B    I try to be impartial as much as I percieve, and I must admit I fully agree with you in my heart, NOW that you are telling me the TRUTH. I wish it was all a lie.  That's unfortunate and actually heart-breaking -- shock for me. I learnt something today, and came to know about yet another contradiction of life, in the 42nd year of my life. Being on a pedestal, and using that height and respect, impart Responsibility.     Here I perhaps shall go a step further than you (or what you know but not said for propriety's sake, on both individual and social levels). Yes it is human to be fallible, and once that happens, certain sets of corrigendum need to corrected. The more authority and trust one develops, the scope to commit errors becomes narrower -- the person definitely can argue on the basis of being Humane (and the 'holier-than-thou' clichés), and he should be answered and corrected on the basis of Humanity,
Anirban Chaudhuri 6:57pm Jun 20
@Suman B

I try to be impartial as much as I percieve, and I must admit I fully agree with you in my heart, NOW that you are telling me the TRUTH. I wish it was all a lie.
That's unfortunate and actually heart-breaking -- shock for me. I learnt something today, and came to know about yet another contradiction of life, in the 42nd year of my life. Being on a pedestal, and using that height and respect, impart Responsibility.

Here I perhaps shall go a step further than you (or what you know but not said for propriety's sake, on both individual and social levels). Yes it is human to be fallible, and once that happens, certain sets of corrigendum need to corrected. The more authority and trust one develops, the scope to commit errors becomes narrower -- the person definitely can argue on the basis of being Humane (and the 'holier-than-thou' clichés), and he should be answered and corrected on the basis of Humanity,
Comment History
Suman Bhowmik
Suman Bhowmik5:19pm Jun 20
doc, what you say is part truth. what you do not, maybe because you did not work with her closely enough, is that to be so taken care of by her or her team, every leper, poor or sick needed to convert first. to accept that jesus was his / her lord. to push in a conversion agenda on those hapless beings was not only to say my god is better than yours (which is a whole load of crap by any yardstick) but also making profit out of human misery. that is despicable in normal, fallible humans. in one who is claimed to be a saint (obviously for pushing a church agenda of increasing flocks of poor lambs) it is a crime beyond pardon!! so while you have every right to believe in the godliness of agnes, the many others who have happened to have worked closely with the moc and are aware of these issues, have an equal, if not stronger right to differ. in every case its an individual opinion and the citizenship of this country has little to do with it. and finally, erudite as you always are & sentimental as you now are, the fact remains that the argument over agnes is often a one of facts versus public image (created by a biased western media, followed by a me-too indian media and gobbled up by a lot ignorant indians - i would venture so much as to say mostly bengalis, the other provinces largely keeping a straight mind - that love hero worship in some form or another). your note therefore makes you as much part of the reality show as everyone else you see `salivating for bread.' ;-)).
Anirban Chaudhuri
Anirban Chaudhuri12:37pm Jun 20
This is bloody outrageous. Both the author and the reader seem to bo psychopaths, and in my opinion, criticizing just for the sake if criticizing.

And even if She's done everything for money or popularity, LET IT BE. We have seen enough of the humanoid sub-species- the 'His/Her Holiness, His Holy Scrupules ('Scriptures' for a group with a lot of common things), His Face and The Intent that lies behind, and The Holy Halo. We know our level of 'Vedic Tolerance', and how much we can take without making a single sound,(at least the Vocal type)...

Let's not bother about efforts at posthumous epitomisation of those who, we (some of us) believe and preach, might have had Hell to be the possible destination of their post-mortem soulless journey.

I have seen Sister Teresa cleaning faeces ('shit' oops!-- 'Crap' for the urbane and the metropolitan), vomittus ('Puke' for the same demographic segment) , pus, infected blood & a range of discharges from a range of human orifices (of which many of us wouldn't be able to tolerate the stench, let alone touch) with a compassionate smile, with a Prayer, and with words of Comfort that make us believe.
So, for all the commandeering and wangles, the dubious tyranny of those she knew, and the possible 'blood donations' she might have managed (according to this personified encyclopedia that reports about the ostentations), I, as an Indian, shall continue to respect the Mother if I truly believe that she might saved and shaped the life of even only One sick leper child, of a much lesser god.
We silently celebrate brutal deaths, rapes, assassinations with consummate ease over our morning coffee. Let's tolerate an eventual birth, born out of destiny's folly. Say what -- we could even politicise this blasphemous act to take over the parliament? ? I see hungry faces.. Okay..I don't know what's cooking in Hitchen's Kitchen so I throw this piece of bread into the crowd called You. Watching this Reality Show is a salivating prospect..
Original Post
Raja Mitra
Raja Mitra6:06am Jun 20
Oh no, Mother!

I was reminded of Sister Agnes (aka Mother Teresa) once again on coming
across the following lines in Christopher Hitchens' review of Joseph
Lelyveld's book on Gandhi.

"When Mother Teresa—another denizen of that unworldly India of redemption by
self-abnegation—had her audience with Pope Paul VI, she reportedly took a
bus to the Vatican and wore only her everyday sari and sandals. I wrote at
the time that, if true, this was not modesty but ostentation."

This of course is greatly at variance with her usual practice of
commandeering Calcutta Corporation ambulances regularly during the 60s & 70s
and travelling around in them for free with her acolyte nuns.

Given that Kolkata's favourite nun used to wangle first-class tickets for
free from airlines managers (' in God's name, for God's work' ) and jet
around all over the globe meeting dubious tyrants & established embezzlers
among others from whom she managed to get many millions of 'donations' which
were subsequently never ever accounted for and get treated at some very good
and expensive hospitals all over the world whenever she was unwell. this was
indeed an ostentatious act, if not a downright hypocritical one. You can
read more details about her duplicity by going through Dr. Aroup
Chatterjee's written deposition to the Vatican about her
http://www.facebook.com/l/6d4aaAnnvTdoi9KkCPC54b_sw4g/www.deeshaa.org/deposition-mother-of-all-myths/ or from this article
http://www.facebook.com/l/6d4aa2CByVywEhzXw75B1vEfOlA/www.deeshaa.org/906/ by the veteran journalist & erstwhile editor of
The Statesman Sunanda K. Datta-Ray published in The Australian over a decade
ago (both reproduced by Dr. Atanu Dey in his blog).

Hitchens who is the author of an interesting book on Mother Teresa entitled
" The Missionary Position : Mother Teresa in Theory & Practice" (Detailed
excerpts from this book can be read at Google Books here Mother Teresa -
Christopher Hitchens from Google
Books< http://www.facebook.com/l/6d4aaUv88Q2wTSwu5Y4ktvzSn5g/books.google.com/books?id=PTgJIjK67rEC&lpg=PP1&pg=PA19%23v%3Donepage&q&f=false>)
had this to say subsequently when the Vatican decided to beatify her.
http://www.facebook.com/l/6d4aav3Qj4EWr0UqSCuTropSuoQ/www.slate.com/id/2090083/

Undaunted by all this of course Kolkata now has a Metro station named after
her. And the unqualified, unthinking adulation is all set to continue.

View Post on Facebook · Edit Email Settings · Reply to this email to add a comment.

HITCHEN's KITCHEN

[[ Christopher Hitchens who is the author of an interesting book on Mother Teresa entitled " The Missionary Position : Mother Teresa in Theory & Practice" (Detailed
excerpts from this book can be read at Google Books here Mother Teresa -
Christopher Hitchens from Google
Books < http://www.facebook.com/l/6d4aa34vqn8fLhHn73taqB6PqXw/books.google.com/books?id=PTgJIjK67rEC&lpg=PP1&pg=PA19%23v%3Donepage&q&f=false>)
had this to say subsequently when the Vatican decided to beatify her.
http://www.facebook.com/l/6d4aaGuR2gFy2oTYQQv78xqQNmQ/www.slate.com/id/2090083/ ]]

************************************

This is bloody outrageous. Both the author and the reader seem to b psychopaths, and in my opinion, criticizing because there might an itch or a "Hitch" active somewhere, just for the sake of criticizing.

And even if She's done everything for money or popularity, LET IT BE. We have seen enough of the humanoid sub-species- the 'His/Her Holiness, His Holy Scrupules ('Scriptures' for a group with a lot of common things), His Face and The Intent that lies behind, and The Holy Halo. We know our level of 'Vedic Tolerance', and how much we can take without making a single sound,(at least the Vocal type)...

Let's not bother about efforts at posthumous epitomisation of those who, we (some of us) believe and preach, might have had Hell to be the possible destination of their post-mortem soulless journey.

I have seen Sister Teresa cleaning faeces ('shit' oops!-- 'Crap' for the urbane and the metropolitan), vomitus ('Puke' for the same demographic segment) , pus, infected blood & a range of discharges from a range of human orifices (of which many of us wouldn't be able to tolerate the stench, let alone touch) with a compassionate smile, with a Prayer, and with words of Comfort that make us believe.

So, for all the commandeering and wangles, the dubious tyranny of those she knew, and the possible 'blood donations' she might have managed (according to this personified encyclopedia that reports about the ostentations), I, as an Indian, shall continue to respect the Mother if I truly believe that she might saved and shaped the life of even only One sick leper child, of a much lesser god.

We silently celebrate brutal deaths, rapes, assassinations with consummate ease over our morning coffee. Let's tolerate an eventual birth, born out of destiny's folly. Say what -- we could even politicise this blasphemous act to take over the parliament? ? I see hungry faces.. Okay..I don't know what's cooking in Hitchen's Kitchen so I throw this piece of bread into the crowd called You. Watching this Reality Show is a salivating prospect..

--- the faceless Indian

Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Respite

No respite
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

BLIGHTY! OUR EXPENSIVE ALMIGHTY

It has been very easy to observe and identify a common trend in the poltical developments in countries of the Middle East and North Africa. And the common Indian is almost compelled to think about it, and try to put it in perspective against the backdrop of India's socio-political status and going upstream to search for relevant issues in the stream of time.

While he might be ridiculed for wasting valuable time to pose as a " socio-political commentator", when he is gasping for breath nose deep in slime. Both hands are full, carrying a handful of brittle plans to defend against the after-shocks of the latest trend of Corruption. His knees shake observing De-spiritualization of India's saffron essence -- the holy brigade casting aside its potentially marketable halo, and jumping into the band-wagon carrying every possible pair of chalk and cheese. Its destination, if at all, is unknown, though as a hardened Indian I feel the toy-train is actually running on a looping track. At night he looks in Wikileaks for bedtime stories to read out to children.

Yet, attention is drawn westwards because some of these have been revolutions, that gained ground by participation of the electronic audio-visual media, and the rapid, undistorted spread of informations about ground reality to every corner of our global village. In a time less than never before, his story-telling may be interrupted by the rain of ash because volcanoes in Tunisia, Egypt, Yemen, Libya, Jordan have erupted big time, and have been spewing molten venom over the last few months.

A Trial in Chicago is breaking the hearts of both the heartless and the broken-hearted. As a result the ghost of 26/11,( or rather the ghastly prospect of the ghost of the guilty in 26/11 getting away unpunished) refuses to go away.

Jehadis are all over the place -- Al Quaida, Lashkar-e-Toiba, Jamaat-Ud-Dawah, Hizbul Mujaheedins, Indian Mujaheedins - genocidal suicide missions seem to be never-ending, (well the prospect of Sublime Biryani and 70 ethereal virgin belles have definitely made its point).

Looking through all these creates a question : why is these barbarians continuing to take up arms, fight and bleed? What is the stake? What is the Core which should be neutralized, around which these bearded mercenaries continue to thump feet in their war-dance.

All eyes are on Pakistan -- host to all sorts of homicidal psychopaths as they continue to plot and plan, interacting with "rogue elements" , former army officers and ex-ISI, who are coming up as killing coaches to deliver human bombs in hundreds every day. Of course the country is bleeding because of its self-made mess.
Diplomatic and Military exercises are in full swing to get the better of these bearded two-legged man-eaters.

I guess it will never be possible because the targets of drone-attacks and Navy Seals intruding under the cover darkness do not make the Core.
The terrorist psyche has to be re-oriented. He must realize the futility of the 'spoils' of Holy War. And here is where Religion comes in, the uncomfortable issue lies in everybody's mind too sensitive to be debated upon, possibly to even confront.

And who is the ultimate instigator of not only the Mumbai terror attack, but all the jehadi attacks, not to mention the more direct wars that India has had to fight against an implacable foe?

No, it's not Pakistan. While this country is the apparent cause for all the bloodshed, it is not the ultimate cause. The ultimate cause of all this wasteful, mindless violence, the ultimate cause behind the very creation of Pakistan itself is Religion -- in other words, God. Or rather, the human perception of this Myth of Divinity. Let the perception stay -- only thing it has to proper and correct.

Religion has wrecked havoc in India too. Or rather religious intolerance is the issue. The demolition of the Babri Masjid -is also, and even more obviously,a manifestation of theo-politics, the lethally vengeful politics of God.
It is not geo-politics but theo-politics which has been responsible for brutal hostilities.

Today everybody is playing theo-politics. And in doing so, we are all, willy-nilly, becoming pawns of the very game that we think we are playing. It is not just Kasab, and the Taliban, and the Al-Qaeda, and Pakistan's ISI, which both exploit, and are, in inevitable turn, exploited by theo-politics. We, in our own India, are also increasingly held to ransom by the politics of religion, the viciously perverted sectarianism of a God with a schizophrenic, split psyche, divided along the razor-edge fault-lines of Hinduism, Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Sikhism, Buddhism, and all the 'isms' that man has invented to hide from heaven's eyes while he creates hell on earth.

It is not just the Taliban. It's Indian qualitative reverse image too, the Sangh-Parivar, is the practitioner and unwilling dupe of theo-politics, equally complicit, equally the propagator as well as the victim of the politics of the religion of a divisive God. The massive price that human civilisation as a whole (not individual societies, communities or races) has incurred in the name of Religion and a highly condemnable God who encourages genocide and fratricide. Religion has been twisted to accommodate the issue at hand.

Can humankind (ah that's a ironically curious word; shouldn't it be human'cruel'?) as a whole afford such a omni-savouring God any longer? Perhaps it's time for those who believe in God-of whatever colour, creed, stripe or nomenclature-to pray to Him(or Her) to turn us all into atheists, or at least agnostics. We would no longer be required to, in the name of a God, no longer believed in, by the grace of the same God, to kill each other to complete annihilation to His greater Glory, and could get on trying to deal with mundane, down-to-earth,and not up-to-heaven problems like poverty, illiteracy, disease and eco-destruction.

All of you who swear every moment of your lives by some kind of Divinity or the other,, seem to know the mind of His Schizophrenic Holiness by the back of your hands. And you are ever-ready to jump to attribute to His schizophrenic Will or to His Cause, any social phenomenon, or actions perpetrated within the civilized society, creating controversy. It is always perverse homicide or genocide, and all kinds of degradation to the deepest of the nadir, a free man/woman/child is subject to :- rape, paedophilia, pervert sexuality within a temple or a church, or child sacrifice.

However you can rest in peace, all of those believes in a God who allows vengeance
..because this will not happen, of course. The more troubled the times (and ours are very troubled indeed, what with global terror, pandemic disease, economic meltdown, greenhouse effect et al), the greater the premium that people pay to God as insurance cover.

Fear and Religion are just two sides of the same coin since prehistory. Prehistoric hominids invented the gods to appease them because storm and lightning, draught and flood, fire and ice, frightened them. And we haven't changed much. Self-invented Fear over caste, race, gender clash and exploitation still hold us to random, and provide us with spurious excuses and enough mistrust to enable us with mutual hatred to fight and kill each other.

My words would have never come into existence if you really respected religion. If you believe Religion is Truth, you should stand up to dissociate your Religion whenever crimes are committed in its name. Be it Hinduism or Islam or Buddhism or.. Etc etc.

Everytime a Hindu has sacrificed a baby girl in the name of Ram, or a Muslin has beheaded a fellow human being in the name of Allah, you have, just by your silence and cowardice, failed to condemn the evil, and most importantly failed to dissociate your Religion from these homophobic fanatics. It is you who have degraded the same religion and its holy teachings (-- those you are so religious about), into a malevolent god who doesn't seem to be the same harmless and hyper-hyped up bloke who believed in Creation of life.

At the moment, terrorism is going on rampantly again in the name of Allah, and societies who should be evolving in consciousness witnessing more respect in and towards humanity, are dragged back into its ancient perceptions when social law is replaced by Islamic law, allowing a neo-hedonism against which not a single Muslim leader has ever stood up. The factor is not Islam. It is the absence of sheer responsibilty of various religious leaders who didn't let the religion evolve and adapt to changing times.

*(I have read all the holy texts that are existent now even the Tibetan Book of the Dead, having been pushed by my interest in history, prehistoric sociology and its wonderful concomittance with anthropology
( specifically anthropo-biology & anthropo-bio-psyciology -- do these terms exist? I guess I was able to guide your attention to the intended direction..but have never found any chapter which let's these rituals to run amock )

Almost 200 years back, laws in Hindu society were sanctified by principles of Manu-Samhita. Widows are socially tortured and raped by temple priests, little girls were married off to old pervert minds to keep alight the continuity of family line (degrading Woman to a vessel to impregnate and reproduce) -- mind you, this was actively facilitated by the girl's parents because the child, according to the Holy Scriptures would face ostracization if not married off before menarche!

Freshly widowed women were drugged and thrown into burning pyres to be roasted alive so that 'feminine sanctity' of the religious institution of marriage ( this barbarian thought still exists, still continues to be perceived) would be preserved to immortality. Her cries would be lost in the din of voices coming up from a dark void so pathetically devoid of soul, who perhaps sought refuge in the high-pitched repetitions of religious incantations, when compassion and guilt threatened to fill up the dark void, persecuting any efforts of repentance. Here I say, religion was used to justify acts of such cruelty. The mourning parents sought refuge from the pain of this barbaric cruelty, in a auto-hypnotised denial, where the religious rulers (the most debauched class in the early decades of the 19th century -- yes, as recent as that) would carry out mass brain-washing in the names of heaven and hell, virtue and vice, again using the 'opium for the masses' to serve their own vested interests including acts of debauchery including sexual exploitation of the simple-minded, unsuspecting village maidens and married women ( emancipation of the soul by consummation with 'God' through his holy emissary, the priests.)

As awareness grew, and formal education was actively pursued by the youth, face of the 19th century renaissance (to be socially persecuted as the face of the renegade) guided by reformers. And they did hound out the barbarism, which had been an age-old inclusion in the socio-religious profile of communities, who carried out social repression by hiding behind pages of the holy texts. These were slowly pushed out by social reforms, (obviously the beginning was strongly attacked by Hindu fanatic zealots). It required a gigantic reformist process by men of wisdom who just didn't quit. Now barbarianism is not there officially. Hindus changed the holy texts by throwing the distorted rubbish.

Islam preaches tolerance too. I have read the Al-Sharif and Al-Hadish (it is important to know what one wishes to put subject to rationalization in context of contemporary trends. They act as milestones in the pathway along which Time guides sociological evolution to follow -- a constant continuity of the inevitable, not necessarily consistent though.) Going through the Scriptures of the Prophet, one has a distinct realization that its message is much more intolerant compared to the essence of other religions.

I would want to point out a very basic thematic truth. These Scriptures, in a way, form a code of conduct for the society of its patrons. I'm not at all qualified to qualify the philosophy of divinity of the Scriptures. Yet the Scriptures are a brilliant commentary that provides insights into sociology of those times, and brilliant literature for studying 'comparative sociology', (if I'm allowed to put it that way, with no intention to distort the language inside the Palace,... well.. as the language of Colonisation too.....)

I would not hide that my perception is of lesser Divinity, and greater Reality as a social code of conduct. A social code of conduct which was laid down to be followed almost 900 years back cannot be expected to accommodate 21st century perceptions of Right and Wrong, of Morality and yes, Relevance too. The reality is that the scholars and religious leaders didn't update the text while everything was getting updated.

Religiosity need not be updated, but organized literature on sociology demands to be updated. One can't understand why there are so few Muslim reformist voices(that can affect) when genocide is carried out, or courts allow punishments like public flogging, stoning to death, amputation of limbs. If a Muslim doesn't feel nauseated to find out that he believes in the same religious beliefs which are exploited to wage war and are glorified in front of the entire world, the impression of Islam on the Non-Muslim is perverse and cruel, nothing close to a divine consciousness who creates things.
.
I am a pantheist. I am not a religious person at all. At various stages of life, my family has been embarrassed by my "paganism" in religious places, in religious circumstances.
But I will always shift to make space for Religion, that is because I respect the human being in a man, that can't depend on someone's take on religion. Such thought-process makes me reaffirm that if I were to live in a world where being religious is an absolute requirement, I would choose Humanism -- tolerant, respectful, and propagates peace.

If Islam is updated, it will be upgraded too. I am sure the world would be a better place if peaceful coexistence of religions with more humane essence.

Till then God be damned. Too many innocent lives. Too much blood. He Is mighty Expensive.

Don't get bothered by me, and you, I am sure, won't bother to bother me. I shall survive somehow. So shall you. Perhaps we could do that together?

--- the faceless Indian, just one in a crowd of a billion.

Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Saturday, June 11, 2011

FAREWELL MAQBOOL FIDA HUSSAIN

As you prepare for The Journey, I feel sad that I could not bid you farewell the way I would have wanted to, on Indian soil. But I am sure you will come back home again, to be reborn and in India too, and I am sure India, by then, will have been reborn to greet you. Because you loved India as much as India loved you.

I shall be awaiting your arrival, your deep, bold and sweeping brush-strokes, and for those silent horses to run wild and free, as free as Freedom, through my heart to make me revel, smile and weep.

And there shall be Redemption on that day.

On that day Destiny will bow down to you, to your dreams and laughter so that peace, and happiness and newer dreams shall greet you and inspire you to great heights of the wisdom of Art, setting aside all the misperceptions, scorn, ridicule and fury. For Hatred's sole victim was Art, and that victimized us all.

Your art was one of the many teachers that taught me that Life still follows the same tides and webs : Good things always happen to good people, no matter What, and How, and When. It has always happened so because Life itself doesn't know the answer if Destiny asked it -- Why? I learnt why The Artist goes ahead and seeks the answer to Why, and new eras of Brilliance begin .. For that is the magic, the charm of Life and Art.

The paintings had all -- The Light and the Darkness that balances it out, of Colour and the Shade that make it high and deep ..it taught me the necessity of antithesis in Art, and how complementary antithesis of one created the other and makes its presence felt.

It is the quality of that 'Feeling' that creates an Emotion. Your art reaffirmed for me that we are all children of Nature, and every new emotion arises in Nature. I learnt for life that it is the Artist who upholds the all important Bridge, a bridge so fragile, between Nature and us.

I know now why Art is an inherent part of our entity - one can choose to believe it or ignore it, but one cannot deny it. And that is why the artist shall always be there in our society. It does not follow numbers or rules which are specific to generations. "Amount" of artists is not even remotely equal or close to that ( as close as how it is to be believed by logic).

It is so imperative that I apologise to you on behalf of all of us, those of us Indians who didn't have the courage to bother to connect to you and to stand by your side, every time you lamented in privacy that you were hurt, and you wanted to come back home and that you never thought less of India -- that you are an Indian, and you have the right to explain on what might have gone wrong that hurt certain parts of India so strongly that you were hounded out. We didn't give you the chance, and neither did we speak on your behalf to ones who were hurt.

India boasts of Tolerance. I don't think anything happened on a scale so large to make India so intolerant so that you left India forever. But on your final journey, I wish not to think of anything but bidding you audieu.

Bon Voyage

--- the faceless Indian

Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Our Roots, our story

A human being is a part of the whole called by us universe, a part limited in time and space.

He experiences himself, his thoughts and feelings as something separated from the rest, a kind of optical delusion of his consciousness. This delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to affection for a few persons nearest to us. The men of wisdom in the ancient eras meditated to contemplate upon the Reason of Life, Behind Birth and Death. Particularly in ancient India, during the Mid-Vedic period, the sages (today one of them would have been called the Philosopher of Philosophers) showed brilliant thinking, pondering over issues beyond staying alive, fighting for territory and of course continuing to reproduce and survive.

I run the risk of being marauded by specialist-anthropologists, for that I should add that these are personal thoughts -- calculated guesses, which tend to tie up loose strings in entirity for me, and I do not formally claim them even as hypotheses. It's just sharing of ideas, as in every human being lies the instinct, in varying degrees to seek for every 'Why' that he sees around him and the knowledge that has come to him down generations.
Anthropological study of the Vedic Period reveals that even the most advanced of civilisations lived with in a society which was based upon 'ethics of tribalism'. There was no precedence for these generations in any walk of life to look back upon, so they went by instincts as a member of Nature's family (just like other species of animals)

Here i get goosebumps to imagine in this tribal background, where people were busy trying to survive, the ancient sages sought answers in the metaphysical realm.

Summarisingly, the ancient wise have left the fruit of their metaphysical pursuits, and early Spiritualism across cultures teach us that our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by widening our circle of compassion to embrace all living creatures.

We should understand that the absolute universality of the law of causality does not necessarily limit a person's freedom, because the law of causality not only enables him to explain the past and predict the future, but also encourages him to use his intelligence to create new causes and attain new results. Here lies the inherent beauty of Life -- its freedom imcluding epistemological freedom. This is the beauty of Nature ans the nature of Beauty. And that freedom prompts me to say that
humankind is a great possibility.

Man can evolve phenomenally or he can remain stagnant - both are possible. That is the beauty of being human.
It's upto us to choose.
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

SHAME ON US

The political atmosphere is one of total anarchy. People are angry. Government has lost control of governance. Political parties are engrossed in the only they are capable of : high-pitched rhetoric, 'slamming' each other, in the most crass of ways. Educated politicians are abusing each other in debates that is being nationally televised.

While an elderly lady lies in coma, with a strong risk of quadriplegia, after being thrashed in the head and upper spine, by brute police excess over a peaceful democratic protest, the man who was leading the demonstration doesn't accept any responsibility, the truth being he was never in control the crowd.

Right Axis leaders are seeking political opportunism, making a sit-in- demonstration in Rajghat 'protesting against the murder of democracy that severely injured common people', and in the same demonstration elderly leaders are dancing (claiming it's their right to dance to patriotic songs) over Gandhiji's mausoleum with smiling faces, to claps by colleagues in nationalist vigour, and one cannot see an iota of 'mourning' and concern for whom they claim to protest -- Height of insensitivity*.

Ruling party leaders are criticizing this insensitivity in press conferences claiming that the 'dancers' have doubtful integrity of character -- Height of cheap populism*.

The man in the centre of the controversy that essentiated forceful externment by police force, is totally confused, has run out of ideas. He still hasn't decided what to do, never having shown showing any responsible foresight, yet he whipped a mass hysteria.

Tihar jail is Delhi is housing 15 top corporate bosses, ministers, bureaucrats, and money launderers -- this provides a perfect insight into India's democratic profile. Terrorists who should have lynched for attacking India and her parliament are being 'looked after' at a cost Rs.20 crores a month. Nobody knows when they shall be subjected to court's verdict.

Middle-class Indians (including many of you who are reading this mail) remain mysteriously silent. They continue to exhibit their disgusting apathy, and shall react only their spouses and children will be affected directly. Shameless cowards, they are the first in line to savour the 'fruits' that others are earning for them by strongly protesting against vested interests and corruption. Safely decorating their secure abodes with spouses and children. Amazing to see the ones who have not made a single sound in the last 2 months, despite so much of active dynamism all around. Sometimes I think these spineless cowards deserve nothing better than these politicians and bureaucrats only.
I guess these ever-compromising apathetic voices, scared to face the consequences of voicing opinions make the most shameful moral 'scam'.
All for today. Till the next episode of kicking your butts with more sarcasm. Do what you best. Eat, drink, defaecate, reproduce, and corrupt the minds of your own children.
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

THE DREAM, THE BILL, AND THE UNHOLY

To

Anna Hazare Sir, my leader.

As a true leader who doesn't compromise ideals at any cost, who leads from the front, and takes the unholy and the dirty by its horns, the entire country trusts you, you have India's unconditional support. We, even those of us who have been cowards, have courage now and follow you with utmost faith. You are the hero of many a story, that of a fight that you led us into, and fought for our pride, honour and self-respect. We dream to tell the story to tell our grandchildren one day.

Let me tell you a story this time -- The true story of me which is still being written in the pages of Time, that shall end one day where Destiny will choose to do. If you've heard it, I feel you need to listen one more time.

Two months back we saw a flicker and a small silhouette. In no time, the flicker became bigger and brighter, to reveal itself before us. It was a Fire never seen before -- a fire that was burning all this time in us, it's just that we didn't know. That Fire, so eager to devour the darkness inside us and around too, burst forth with a fury that came from our hearts, and it united us in a brotherhood -- that which had silently suffered all this time.

That day we dreamed. The small silhouette was now a life size shadow for us, of a
septuagenarian who was carrying the torch with the flame. We saw you. You inspired us leading from the front, and to raise our voices and ask questions. The entire country came out into the streets and rejoiced, celebrating the fact that all of us had suffered from the same, and dreamed a common dream.

Formally speaking it was a Bill that could control and prevent Corruption. We, the common Indians, never looked upon it as a weapon easily available to the common man to destroy whatever he disliked. We didn't dream of being all-powerful fascists to misuse it arbitrarily. What we believed is that it would be the voice of every Indian that would reach the top-most echelons of power, quickly and convey strong and direct messages from us. If 'they' would refuse to listen, it would make sure it would reach those who would. And everything would be done democratically, us following laws and provisions that would be effective. We believed in our leader as you promised, who represent our voices, griefs, and protests.

Let me fast-forward events to the moment right here, and right now. It's back. The thing we suffered from so long. We were disgusted of. We dreaded. It's a mess right now. Nonsense protest by a shady spiritual leader, joined by the saffron brigade, and a mysteriously ineffective governance that dances and battles at the same time. The very people who ran for cover two months back in panic, are all over the place now like before. Disgraced jokers are back to their jesting best.

Sir, Where are We in this scene? Who is voicing Us? Who is asking how We feel and what we Want? We have never minced words in our protests, believing in each other's faith. We supported whom we saw caring for us, promising to fight for us.

And We will not mince words now too. What are our heroes doing? Are you in touch with us? Are you listening to us like before? In spite of this Ramdev disaster of an incident where everybody messed things up, what happened to the Bill?

In a bid to condemn the govt's action, you and your team boycotted the panel meeting today. Who or what is the Priority? Solidarity with Ramdev, or The Bill? I am asking so because we believe in time-bound processes that deliver. Without the time factor we have dreamed to dream for 62 long years, with leaders in every generation promising us good times, and better times.
We appreciate concern about Ramdev. We are concerned about him even if you hadn't. He created his mess himself, and he suffered. We have condemned that, our sympathies remain with him on humanitarian grounds. So have you.

I ask you, Anna Hazare Sir, is he bigger than us? Did you ask us the extent to which we, the Indian people who put their faith in you, want or can compromise our own demands to show sympathy, on humanitarian grounds, for Ramdev? Do you still know about who and what we care and how much?

I still have my faith on you, Anna Hazare Sir. But I don't do that for you to express on my behalf, my sympathy and solidarity (the tone has a suspiciously political overtone that wasn't there) with Ramdev. I hope you haven't taken me for granted or losing touch with reality, with Us.

You said today you showed protest against the govt being not serious. Yesterday you said you'll boycott 6th June meeting in protest against the way the govt has dealt with Ramdev. Can you feel my insecurity, the question and the ambiguity that's started to plague my mind which, at the moment, is not feeling very hopeful?

Questions are blowing in the wind. I hope you are hearing them

--- the faceless Indian

[[Dissection of Conscience - A doctor's diary
http://jogyou963.blogspot.com ]]
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

THE BILL, THE FIGHT, AND THE HOLY

To
Anna Hazare Sir, my leader.

It's back. The thing we suffered from so long. We were disgusted of. We dreaded. Two months back we saw a flicker and a small silhouette. In no time, the flicker became bigger and brighter, to reveal itself before you and me. It was a Fire never seen before -- a fire, that was burning all this time ins you and me, it's just that we didn't know. The Fire, so eager to devour the darkness inside us, burst out of the darkness that ruled our hearts and heads, united us in a brotherhood -- that which had silently suffered. That day we dreamed. The small silhouette was now a life size shadow of a
septuagenarian who was carrying the torch with the flame. We saw you. You inspired us leading from the front, and inspired us to raise our voices and ask questions. The entire country came out into the streets and rejoiced, celebrating the fact that all of us had suffered from the same, and dreamed a common dream.

Formally speaking it was a Bill that could control and prevent Corruption. We, the common Indians, never looked upon it as weapon available to the common man to destroy whatever he disliked. We didn't dream about being all-powerful fascists to misuse it arbitrarily.
It would be the voice of every Indian that would reach the top-most echelons of power, quickly and convey strong and direct messages from us. If 'they' refuse to listen, it made sure it would reach those who would. And everything would be done democratically, as laws and provisions that would be effective.
We believed in our leader as you promised you would represent our voices, griefs, and protests.

Fast-forward events to the moment right here, and right now. It's a mess right now. Nonsense protest by a shady spiritual leader, joined by the saffron brigade, and a mysteriously ineffective governance that danced and battled in the same time. The very people who ran for cover two months back in panic, are all over the place now like before. Disgraced jokers are back to their jesting best.

Sir, Where are We? Who is voicing Us? Who is asking how We feel and what we Want? We have never minced words in our protests, believing in each other's faith. We supported whom we saw caring for us, promising to fight for us.

And We will not mince words now too. What are our heroes doing? Are you in touch with us? Are you listening to us like before? In spite of this Ramdev disaster of an incident where everybody messed things up, what happened to the Bill?

In his bid to condemn the govt's action, you and your team boycotted the panel meeting today. Who or what is the Priority? Solidarity with Ramdev, or The Bill. Ramdev created a mess himself, and he suffered. We have condemned that, our sympathies remain with him on humanitarian grounds. For you, Anna Hazare Sir, is he bigger than us? Did you ask us the extent to which we, the Indian people who put their faith in you, want or can compromise our own demands to show sympathy, on humanitarian grounds, for Ramdev? Do you still know about who and what we care and how much?

I still have my faith on you, Anna Hazare Sir. I don't do that to show my sympathy and solidarity (the tone has a suspiciously political overtone that wasn't there) with Ramdev. I hope you haven't taken me for granted or losing touch with reality, with Us.

You say today you showed protest against the govt being not serious. Yesterday you said you'll boycott 6th June meeting in protest against the way the govt has dealt with Ramdev. Can you feel my insecurity, the question and the ambiguity that's started to plague my mind which, at the moment, is not feeling very hopeful?

Questions are blowing in the wind. I hope you are hearing them

--- the faceless Indian
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Sunday, June 5, 2011

FREE-FOR-ALL AT MIDNIGHT

The government of India has got to come up with a honest answer that befits a query into why it cracked down on a peaceful hunger-strike so hard, that too in the middle of the night, that innocent people were 'dealt' with tear-gas, water-cannon, lathicharge and brickbats. An excuse that a minute section of the protestors had tried to stop police personnel by pelting stones doesn't stand at all.

Describing it as a shocking episode is an understatement -- I am too shocked to search for stronger words. If an answer doesn't come up, then the episode on the 5th of June 2011 that created an Indian mid-summer night's nightmare would go down in the historical pages of Infamy as one of the most heinous acts that Independent India has ever seen.

This is certainly not the way to deal with a nonviolent protest no matter how threatening the verbal aggression was perceived on Ramdev's platform of protest. He was certainly not instigating his audience to violence.

According to reports, even at 11:30pm, some negotiations were on, with the government sending the second draft, modified, of the day. And there was an impression too that the hunger-strike would be called at 12 noon today. What happened in the next 2 hrs with an emergency cabinet meeting at the highest level, that the govt decided to act suddenly and in the middle of the night?

The Delhi police's official version is that official permission for a hunger-strike was not sought by Ramdev and co. Does that necessitate a sudden crackdown at midnight so much so that many, including women, children and old people were beaten up and tear-gas was used?

First you give a suspiciously regal VVIP reception with 4 cabinet ministers present at the airport. You negotiate for 2 days meekly, including the first one in a 6-star hotel behind closed doors. And then within two hours of forwarding a modified draft-proposal -- the second of the day, you twist your policy of negotiation right around on its head, put on iron gloves, and crack down on an unarmed peaceful crowd, to negate the hunger-strike of the 'opponent' in issue, no matter who and what his issue is, how impractical his demands were?

It was a very palpable panic reaction of the government, one that the government miserably failed to camouflage. The sudden "will-not-tolerate-nonsense" steely attitude deep at night, (as if the ruling party gained "enlightenment" after all these frustrating decades) just seems to have given its real face away. It is very, very surprising, keeping in mind the presence of a couple of seasoned troubleshooters in the cabinet, it should have much more 'political' and shrewd.

Perhaps, in face of the severe political onslaught that's egged the opposition on, the sustained effort of the central government behind having to explain and defend the series of scams, and simultaneously trying to balance the coalition equation, has caused its think-tank some possible 'mental fatigue'. The government has repeatedly failed as far as political foresight is concerned -- it seems to have become an oversight.

I am least bothered about Ramdevji's political future (now all the more so, the way he messed it up yesterday, by reacting immaturely to Kapil Sibal's distribution of his 'letter' in the evening press conference - that's my perception, it needn't be the truth) -- the one in which he'd declared and put his consenting signature on, that he'll call off his fast on Sunday at 12 noon if the govt conceded certain points. I guess Ramdev hadn't seen it coming -- the govt 'releasing' his declaration in the press, because he had consciously witheld the specifics of the letter, from the crowd in Ramleela Maidan. He changed his pitch and the main 'issue' at that moment, immediately after he was informed about Sibal's 'betrayal'.

Here the issue of Black Money takes centre-stage. Possibly the script was something like: He became agressive in his bid to deal with the 'betrayal' in public (that was certainly a thing he hadn't foreseen) -- the aggression made him make impractical demands, that he won't relent unless the govt responded with drafts in all the issues, a truly unfair demand -- that can't be done within a few days with a gun on its head).
The govt too felt threatened by his new pitch and panicked, because by now the "black money" issue was in danger of exploding right in its face, the more Baba would continue, the stronger(and angrier) the public would be instigated too, and in a short time.

And here we have the result -- both Ramdevji and the govt messed it up big time. Whatever the actual script might have been, one should keep the poorly rehearsed drama far away from contemplation and turn its focus on the after-effect of Big Mess-up. And it gets angry, very angry at the police having been brutal on women, the old people, and definitely the way it took Baba off RamLeela Maidan.

The endless political demonstrations and rallies, the ones really threatening and out-of-control, with goons blatantly conducting the show, the ones which make us more frustrated by the day, continue to take place, causing extreme discomfort to the common man. These are handled with kid-gloves, and shamelessly nonsensical political oneupsmanship. And peaceful, harmless women, children and old men are teargassed and lathicharged.. This is certainly not democratic governance.

I might not conform to Ramdevji's takes as far polity is concerned, neither do I agree with the way he thinks to execute his plans, and this personal disagreement with the intentions and policies of Ramdevji might go to the point of extremely cynical dislike.
But I will NOT agree to him being pushed back to his proper place, at the cost of disrespecting the institution of Indian democracy that empower the citizen with basic human rights. It's our duty to condemn any action that is undemocratic and goes against the sanctity of Humanism.

Nothing can justify it. And we won't take any justification. WE SHOULD PROTEST. LET'S HEAR EACH OTHER'S VOICES.

Jai Hind.


Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

PANIC REACTION SHOCKING

Unless the Indian government comes with a fitting answer to why it cracked down on a peaceful hunger-strike so hard, that too in the middle of the night, that innocent people
was dealt with tear-gas, lathicharge and brickbats (even if a minute section of the people tried to stop police personnel with stone-pelting), yesterday's shocking episode would be one of the most heinous acts in the history of Independent India..

This is certainly not the way to deal with a nonviolent protest no matter how threatening the verbal aggression was perceived from Ramdev's platform. He was certainly not instigating his audience to violence.

According to reports, even at 11:30pm, some negotiations were on, with the government sending the second draft, modified, of the day. And there was an impression too that the hunger-strike would be called at 12 noon today.
What happened in the next 2 hrs with an emergency cabinet meeting at the highest level, that the govt decided to act suddenly and in the middle of the night? The Delhi police's official version is that official permission for a hunger-strike was not sought by Ramdev and co. Does that necessitate a sudden crackdown at midnight so much so that many, including women and old people were physically beaten up, and tear-gas was used?

First you give a suspiciously regal VVIP reception with 4 cabinet ministers present at the airport. You negotiate for 2 days meekly, including the first one in a 6-star hotel behind closed doors. And then within two hours of forwarding a modified draft-proposal -- the second of the day, you twist your policy of negotiation right around on its head, put on iron gloves, and crack down on an unarmed peaceful crowd, to negate the hunger-strike of the 'opponent' in issue, no matter who and what his issue is, how impractical his demands were?

This is certainly not democratic governance.
It should explain its action to the entire country, and that has to accommodate a very strong reason to justify the way it decimated the opponent.

The endless political demonstrations and rallies, the ones really threatening and out-of-control, with goons blatantly conducting the show, the ones which make us more frustrated by the day, continue to take place, causing extreme discomfort to the common man. These are countered with kid-gloves, and shamelessly nonsensical political oneupsmanship. And peaceful, harmless women and old men are teargassed and lathicharged..

Fiercely condemnable and every citizen should protest actively.

Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Saturday, June 4, 2011

HOLY LINGUISTIC!

I Just saw on TV (@ 7:45pm, 3rd June, 2011)-- His Holiness Shri Shri Ramdev Baba claimed that the central government has agreed to teaching medicine and engineering in regional languages.
So

1) there are 24 languages and 576 dialects, at least.

2)is ka matlab hain ki all text-books (desi & videsi) are to be translated in least in 8-10 languages if not 24.
Question is not when(if one thinks about the necessary infrastructure) but the sahi disha.
3) toh agar, 5 yrs down the line a 3rd year Tamil undergraduate med student shall want to exchange ideas with a Gujarati counterpart, we will need 2 translators - Tamil & Gujrati. Or dono ko Gujarati or Tamil me expert (tell me the Hindi word for 'expert' -- I am ashamed for my ignorance).

4) the cliché argument is all countries (the maximum brunt is borne by European & South American countries) speak, and work in their own national languages. I wonder how many countries have got at least 5 other registered regional languages in addition to the national one.

5)Main yeh janna chahunga ki if a Mizo doctor is discussing medicine with a Spanish (Basque or Catalan) in a medical conference in Tokyo attended by 50 Japanese doctors, how things shall proceed even with the help of electronic translator. I want to know.

6) if a research is being conducted by a team of 5 doctors, Punjabi, Marathi, Bihari, Telegu and Assamese, what shall be the language for constant interaction. And that of the research papers. So there shall be 5 languages to translate the papers, to be read by at least 5 eager doctors -- Gujarati, Malayali, Bengali, Oriya, Mizo.

APART from these expected replies : that
* His Holiness has been misquoted by the media or me, or
* been perceived in the wrong context, or
* me having commented prematurely before having gone through the entire speech, or
* me being an obsessed pathological liar,

Please enlighten me. I am absolutely ignorant.

There are at least 27 relevant questions that are in my mind. I don't want to overshoot my mouth off, apart from the natural curiosity about such prospect in Law & other subjects

With respect to all,
Jai Hind.
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
"It is important to just listen for a while instead of speaking." -- My teacher
------------------------------------------------------

Friday, June 3, 2011

JAN LOKPAL BILL : OUR HOLY FATHERS AND PATERNAL AFFLICTION

A few weeks back, we saw and were ourselves part of a massive social movement against corruption at any level of governance or bureaucracy, not to mention in our own lives too. Anna Hazare led from the front. One of the factors which made the movement such a big uprising was the absence of politics. We even saw a couple of politicians being booed away by shouting protesters when they tried to jump in, in a brazen and audacious strength never seen before, protesting voices that seemed to come from you and me.

There was nothing calculated about it. Anna didn't know how many people would protest and how. It was the Spontaneity that surprised our own selves, and put the government on a backfoot. The Satyagraha was called off when the government gave in.
I don't think we rooted for Baba Ramdev when we fasted, or he was part of the 'package' that the mass protest rooting for a corruption-free India, took inspiration.
I tell you -- the mass will not be there this time, whoever is fasting wherever.

Whatever Ramdevji did was premature, and it allowed the Home Minister (who is in the Lokpal Bill panel) to assert : "..the members of the Civil Society are divided in opinion." He didn't mean the 5 who are in the panel. He meant Ramdev's demands. This gentleman should keep himself to the job he thinks he does well. Why is he being allowed to enter the issue in the way that the country observes? He might be having millions of 'fans' in heaven and on earth, he is most welcome to support the cause, but since when has he taken up the 'mantle' of being one of the voices of the Cause. On that note,which I hope will not offend one for that is not my intention, I must say I wouldn't like a Yoga exponent representing my voice against corruption, who wishes to cure the "disease of homosexuality with herbal medicine."

Ordinary apolitical people like me are perceiving an atmosphere of a Tamasha that's gaining momentum, and this is Very Very Disappointing. And we are feeling devastated, and utterly frustrated, and now I understand why the country continues to be in the state of utter mess despite having patriotic citizens. The planned Tamasha is Ram Leela Maidan later this week is likely to see more 'mass support' by 'paid' followers of the Divine Cause, shouting and sloganeering, and that will portray a very, very distorted face of India, the face we have continued ignore due to personal prejudices --- the very contradiction that lies unfettered in India's consciousness. If we do not act now, nobody will ever act in future, nor mentioning the painful heartbreak of 1.2 million Indians.

Every action has a time. (If one prepones or postpones it, the entire action is nullified in effect. Exactly what the government seemed to be trying to do by throwing the rule-book back, that disappointed members of Civil Society 3 days back). As a commoner I will not like to dissect the constitutional and technical aspects of the consensus that was reached then. Not that I can't. But the son of a farmer who took his own life in Vidarbha last year out of hunger and heartbreak wouldn't. He wouldn't care, not at this stage.

I have got no issues at all with anybody coming up with any form of non-violent protest, against any institution if the agenda is pro-people and pro-India, no matter who might be uncomfortable with that. But a false perception is defusing out to India. Please let him not interfere with the Specific Process that is on roll at the moment regarding interactions in the Lokpal Bill panel. It is giving the government, or that part of it with vested interests, chances to sabotage the process, the specific process of what should be included in the draft. It is diluting the effect that the mass movement had brought about, no matter how patriotic somebody's intention might be. And that is where it is getting prematurely politicised (we can't avoid that in the future, but in the Right stage). And This is where Anna Hazare scored -- no ambiguities in his words, and his staunch resistance to let in any sort of political gamesmanship that might threaten to divert the focus off the real issue. He represented Balance, as a Responsible leader.

Today it is 'black money'. Tomorrow it shall be 'female infanticide'. Day after tomorrow, it would be 'BPO and Rs.20/- a day'. Everything is valid and correct. But it has to be organised and focus as perfectly as possible. We need Responsibility now, not unharnessed emotion (it would have been relevant if we were trying to make a mass movement, like the one 6 weeks before. And it is Our responsibility to do that and share. We owe it to the dead farmer's son.

The only point I shall continue to comment on with utmost humility, no matter what, is the issue of the Jan Lokpal Bill which is yet to be drafted conclusively and to be passed in Parliament. A specific momentum has gathered, and it's our duty to thwart any factor -- animate or inanimate, irrespective of caste, gender, religion, financial condition, rural or urban origins, that can decelerate the process. Let's keep our focus on that. And it points exactly to one of the reasons why Ramdevji should tread carefully as far as the Lokpal Bill is concerned.

The issue of the Prime Minister's Office and the Supreme Court related to the Jan Lokpal Bill has continued to confuse the mind of the common Indian. Everybody associated with the Jan Lokpal Bill seems to be giving touch-in-cheek monosyllabic answer, and the fumbling phonetic intrinsics are adding to the confusion. Who is this holy Father to opine on whether the PMO and the judiciary should be kept out of the proposed ambit?

I have no doubt about the truth of a report because I myself watched Ramdevji say that he is against the idea of the issue of the Prime Minister's Office and the Supreme Court coming under the ambit of the Jan Lokpal Bill. I watched him saying these very words on a TV news channel on 31st.May, at a convention in Madhya Pradesh (related to his Swabhiman Yatra, I guess). I felt all the more sad as I watched him on the same news channel yesterday evening, saying that his words have been 'misqouted' or have been 'perceived in the wrong context' by the media, when he was asked by Arnab Goswami to clarify his take on the issue of the Prime Minister's Office and the Supreme Court coming under the umbrella of the Jan Lokpal Bill. I still fail to comprehend what he actually meant. The Indian commoner has become tired of such ambiguities -- one of the reasons why we all have developed a wholesome apathy to political exercises, no matter what and where, and lack political consciousness.

The Indian common man has become tired to the point of disgust and ironic amusement, having been at the receiving end of the infamously comical "misquoted or wrongly contextualised" for years, as and when eminent people have rushed to utter these words at the drop of a hat, whenever caught on the wrong foot. And this is where and how Mistrust creeps in the equation, and we, ourselves, let vested interests capitalize on such avoidable cracks in the solidarity of India's collective consciousness.

In times of confusion and impatient unrest like now, (I guess it's natural when a unique democracy like India stands on the threshold of a controlled implosion and changes long overdue, some being radical), I find the 'silence' on our part deafening and scary too. And unless we do not listen to each other and know each other, we would be guilty of not being compatriots, despite being responsible citizens of the same country.

It's our voices that matter. At least the Great Indian Silence (a deafening one, which seems to have been passed down generations since India turned Republic in 1950) seems to have been broken, and I hope the trend shall continue to flourish. I am not picking out individual perceptions. But it is my responsibility to speak out if I see a conflict of interest as far as the Lokpal Bill drafting and its validation in Parliament. (I hope our common focus remains there still). On that note,which I hope will not offend one for that is not my intention, I must say I wouldn't like a Yoga exponent representing my voice against corruption, who wishes to cure the "disease of homosexuality with herbal medicine."

We cannot do without debates as long as the focus is unanimously identified, and we consciously refrain from confronting each other with *individual perceptions about each other*, thus edging out the core issue and distorting the order of our *common priorities. Active debates with full freedom of expression shall enable us to understand each other, criticize each other, and learn from each other -- something needed so direly, if we decide to protest and fight shoulder to shoulder. That is one democratic way without distorting propriety, by which every dark corner of India, ignored before, can be enlightened, enlightening our own selves too.
India cannot agree if Indians do not agree to disagree.
Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
Everywhere I go I find that a poet has been
there before me (Sigmund Freud)
------------------------------------------------------

JAN LOKPAL BILL : OUR HOLY FATHERS AND PATERNAL AFFLICTION

A few weeks back, we saw and were ourselves part of a massive social movement against corruption at any level of governance or bureaucracy, not to mention in our own lives too. Anna Hazare led from the front. One of the factors which made the movement such a big uprising was the absence of politics. We even saw a couple of politicians being booed away by shouting protesters when they tried to jump in, in a brazen and audacious strength never seen before, protesting voices that seemed to come from you and me.

There was nothing calculated about it. Anna didn't know how many people would protest and how. It was the Spontaneity that surprised our own selves, and put the government on a backfoot. The Satyagraha was called off when the government gave in.
I don't think we rooted for Baba Ramdev when we fasted, or he was part of the 'package' that the mass protest rooting for a corruption-free India, took inspiration.
I tell you -- the mass will not be there this time, whoever is fasting wherever.

Whatever Ramdevji did was premature, and it allowed the Home Minister (who is in the Lokpal Bill panel) to assert : "..the members of the Civil Society are divided in opinion." He didn't mean the 5 who are in the panel. He meant Ramdev's demands. This gentleman should keep himself to the job he thinks he does well. Why is he being allowed to enter the issue in the way that the country observes? He might be having millions of 'fans' in heaven and on earth, he is most welcome to support the cause, but since when has he taken up the 'mantle' of being one of the voices of the Cause. On that note,which I hope will not offend one for that is not my intention, I must say I wouldn't like a Yoga exponent representing my voice against corruption, who wishes to cure the "disease of homosexuality with herbal medicine."

Ordinary apolitical people like me are perceiving an atmosphere of a Tamasha that's gaining momentum, and this is Very Very Disappointing. And we are feeling devastated, and utterly frustrated, and now I understand why the country continues to be in the state of utter mess despite having patriotic citizens. The planned Tamasha is Ram Leela Maidan later this week is likely to see more 'mass support' by 'paid' followers of the Divine Cause, shouting and sloganeering, and that will portray a very, very distorted face of India, the face we have continued ignore due to personal prejudices --- the very contradiction that lies unfettered in India's consciousness. If we do not act now, nobody will ever act in future, nor mentioning the painful heartbreak of 1.2 million Indians.

Every action has a time. (If one prepones or postpones it, the entire action is nullified in effect. Exactly what the government seemed to be trying to do by throwing the rule-book back, that disappointed members of Civil Society 3 days back). As a commoner I will not like to dissect the constitutional and technical aspects of the consensus that was reached then. Not that I can't. But the son of a farmer who took his own life in Vidarbha last year out of hunger and heartbreak wouldn't. He wouldn't care, not at this stage.

I have got no issues at all with anybody coming up with any form of non-violent protest, against any institution if the agenda is pro-people and pro-India, no matter who might be uncomfortable with that. But a false perception is defusing out to India. Please let him not interfere with the Specific Process that is on roll at the moment regarding interactions in the Lokpal Bill panel. It is giving the government, or that part of it with vested interests, chances to sabotage the process, the specific process of what should be included in the draft. It is diluting the effect that the mass movement had brought about, no matter how patriotic somebody's intention might be. And that is where it is getting prematurely politicised (we can't avoid that in the future, but in the Right stage). And This is where Anna Hazare scored -- no ambiguities in his words, and his staunch resistance to let in any sort of political gamesmanship that might threaten to divert the focus off the real issue. He represented Balance, as a Responsible leader.

Today it is 'black money'. Tomorrow it shall be 'female infanticide'. Day after tomorrow, it would be 'BPO and Rs.20/- a day'. Everything is valid and correct. But it has to be organised and focus as perfectly as possible. We need Responsibility now, not unharnessed emotion (it would have been relevant if we were trying to make a mass movement, like the one 6 weeks before. And it is Our responsibility to do that and share. We owe it to the dead farmer's son.

The only point I shall continue to comment on with utmost humility, no matter what, is the issue of the Jan Lokpal Bill which is yet to be drafted conclusively and to be passed in Parliament. A specific momentum has gathered, and it's our duty to thwart any factor -- animate or inanimate, irrespective of caste, gender, religion, financial condition, rural or urban origins, that can decelerate the process. Let's keep our focus on that. And it points exactly to one of the reasons why Ramdevji should tread carefully as far as the Lokpal Bill is concerned.

The issue of the Prime Minister's Office and the Supreme Court related to the Jan Lokpal Bill has continued to confuse the mind of the common Indian. Everybody associated with the Jan Lokpal Bill seems to be giving touch-in-cheek monosyllabic answer, and the fumbling phonetic intrinsics are adding to the confusion. Who is this holy Father to opine on whether the PMO and the judiciary should be kept out of the proposed ambit?

I have no doubt about the truth of a report because I myself watched Ramdevji say that he is against the idea of the issue of the Prime Minister's Office and the Supreme Court coming under the ambit of the Jan Lokpal Bill. I watched him saying these very words on a TV news channel on 31st.May, at a convention in Madhya Pradesh (related to his Swabhiman Yatra, I guess). I felt all the more sad as I watched him on the same news channel yesterday evening, saying that his words have been 'misqouted' or have been 'perceived in the wrong context' by the media, when he was asked by Arnab Goswami to clarify his take on the issue of the Prime Minister's Office and the Supreme Court coming under the umbrella of the Jan Lokpal Bill. I still fail to comprehend what he actually meant. The Indian commoner has become tired of such ambiguities -- one of the reasons why we all have developed a wholesome apathy to political exercises, no matter what and where, and lack political consciousness.

The Indian common man has become tired to the point of disgust and ironic amusement, having been at the receiving end of the infamously comical "misquoted or wrongly contextualised" for years, as and when eminent people have rushed to utter these words at the drop of a hat, whenever caught on the wrong foot. And this is where and how Mistrust creeps in the equation, and we, ourselves, let vested interests capitalize on such avoidable cracks in the solidarity of India's collective consciousness.

In times of confusion and impatient unrest like now, (I guess it's natural when a unique democracy like India stands on the threshold of a controlled implosion and changes long overdue, some being radical), I find the 'silence' on our part deafening and scary too. And unless we do not listen to each other and know each other, we would be guilty of not being compatriots, despite being responsible citizens of the same country.

It's our voices that matter. At least the Great Indian Silence (a deafening one, which seems to have been passed down generations since India turned Republic in 1950) seems to have been broken, and I hope the trend shall continue to flourish. I am not picking out individual perceptions. But it is my responsibility to speak out if I see a conflict of interest as far as the Lokpal Bill drafting and its validation in Parliament. (I hope our common focus remains there still). On that note,which I hope will not offend one for that is not my intention, I must say I wouldn't like a Yoga exponent representing my voice against corruption, who wishes to cure the "disease of homosexuality with herbal medicine."

We cannot do without debates as long as the focus is unanimously identified, and we consciously refrain from confronting each other with *individual perceptions about each other*, thus edging out the core issue and distorting the order of our *common priorities. Active debates with full freedom of expression shall enable us to understand each other, criticize each other, and learn from each other -- something needed so direly, if we decide to protest and fight shoulder to shoulder. That is one democratic way without distorting propriety, by which every dark corner of India, ignored before, can be enlightened, enlightening our own selves too.
India cannot agree if Indians do not agree to disagree.

Sent from my BlackBerry®Smartphone
------------------------------------------------------
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri M.B.B.S
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India
------------------------------------------------------
Everywhere I go I find that a poet has been
there before me (Sigmund Freud)
------------------------------------------------------

Monday, May 30, 2011

Realizations & Reality

When we look around us to see and understand, we actually try to understand what has been called Reality by our forefathers, one that flows along the stream of Time.

Understanding this Reality helps us know how we have evolved. We learn and realize that evolving into more advanced forms increases the specificity of their attributes, and make them more different and independent of each other, despite cohabiting the same bracket that encloses the primitive, unevolved form. In effect these brackets contain anthropological singularities with fewer complexities. Studying these 'singularities' helps us retrace the path along Time through prehistory, back to our origin.

We also believe that this evolution has been progressing faster and faster over time though nobody till now has figured out a strong Reason behind it. This is actually the most dominant perception amongst us. Greater possibilities of evolving into more varieties bring more and more people into its fold of belief --  that the Pace of our evolution has an element of Acceleration. Studying History of Mankind, and trying to correlate and connect the dots in where History has tended to be vague, keeping in mind the parallel movements of anthropological and archaeological revelations give us this information - the 'effective degree' of evolution that has taken place over a given span of time, say 70,000 years back had taken a far more wider span of time to occur  amongst us, or rather when a lesser evolved species (which we can claim to be our "forefathers"), walked upon our planet say two million years ago. In a way, what it tells us is that the more primitive we are, the greater variability of perceptions we possess. The spectrum that is available for us to study across its height and depth is much more wider. That leaves us with more freedom to ponder upon, more choices, more perspectives, and thus more 'depth of knowledge' for us to acquire. I would like to dampen this 'reassuring or lucrative' perception that most people develop in a bid to completely understand origin of species, because man, by nature, wants to learn, to seek for answers that provide more insights into our 'origin'.

We tend to define our reality by the words that we use, both with the spoken word, as well as the words we never say. Yet reality can only be seen in the absence of thought and belief when it comes to understanding our own selves. The reality of the other person lies not in what he reveals but in what he cannot reveal. Therefore to understand man, we should listen not to what he says but rather to what he does not say.
There is nothing more important to true growth than realizing -- man is not the voice of his mind. Man is what he hears from his surroundings. When his intention changes the way to understand things, the things that his intention wants to understand change too. This is the actualization of  transformation. Of Change. 
Inherent in every Intention and Desire is the mechanics for its Fulfillment. Intention and Desire in the field of pure potentiality have infinite organizing power. And when we introduce an intention in the fertile ground of pure potentiality, we put this infinite organizing power to work for us. Everybody has a talent. What is rare is the courage to nurture it in solitude and to follow the talent to the dark places it leads to. 

Each of us comes into this world with a specific destiny -- we have something to fulfill, some message has to be delivered, some work has to be completed. No one is here accidentally -- we all are here meaningfully. There is a Purpose behind us all. The Whole intends to do something through us.

When a child is born, he is completely free from preformed perceptions, having still not been affected by the "conditioning" through which the human mind lets itself get influenced by as it moves on with time..

Soon the child's clear eye is clouded over by ideas and opinions, preconceptions and abstractions. Simple free being becomes encrusted with the burdensome armor of the ego. Not until years later does an instinct come that a vital sense of mystery has been withdrawn. Some of us, with sensitive seeking minds, "realize" this fallacy  somewhere ahead in life, learning through events and experiences. The sun glints through the pines, and the heart is pierced in a moment of beauty and strange pain, like a memory of paradise. After that day, we become seekers.

There comes a time when the pain of continuing exceeds the pain of stopping. At that moment, a threshold is crossed. What seemed unthinkable becomes thinkable. Slowly, the realization emerges that the choice to continue what one has been doing is the choice to live in discomfort, and the choice to stop what he has been doing is the choice to breathe deeply and freely again. Once that realization has emerged, one can either honour it or ignore it, but he cannot forget it.

The Truth I have realized after consciously unlearning a few basic concepts of life is : What has become known can not become unknown again.
---- Sent from my BlackBerry®
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology&Critical Care)
Mumbai, India

Everywhere I go I find that a poet has been
there before me.(Sigmund Freud)
---------------------------------------------------------------------

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Left out of Power - Bengal Elections 2011

In view of the recent defeat Mamta Banerjee handed out to the Left Front, ousting them out of power contemptuously, supporters - both in the Trinamool Party and in the electorate - might be taking pride in the huge margin by which the Left got defeated, and as a matter of fact, it shall be unusual if that doesn't happen and one can't blame them for that. Yet the fact that there's no significant opposition in a Legislative Assembly can be potentially harmful for any government, enough to keep one in discomfort.

For any system to function properly, an optimal balance is needed -- a 'good' opposition (essentially a counter-debating process) in case of a governing system. Though it depends on the 'quality' of opposition, numbers matter in most states in India as the 'quality' factor has gone for a toss years back.

Now the Left Front is grappling while trying to form a proper opposition in the 2011 Assembly (leave alone the fact that there is not a suitable man to be the Leader of the Opposition). While it shouldn't have such a 'threat' if the exercises in the Assembly are done in copy-book style (what I mean is more or less a spirit in which intelligent debates are conducted) including acknowledgment of the mutual respect between the 2 sides(inspite of win/lose in the political front)that should be there, the uncivilized way in which govt & opposition go at each other with hammer & tongs (not unique in India of course) negate such fancy -- one of the reasons why 'political culture', has assumed such a dirty, negatively fallacious impression in the common citizen's mind and why (few)good politicians of intent are sadly dismissed away by sweeping commentaries people/institutions are given the chance to make.

The New CM, having coming to power the hard way, has to be watchful of the 'corrupt power', power empowers the corrupt with. A very fine and subtle balance - yet one is hopeful that both politicians and we, the electorate have learnt the lesson, for our own good.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
 Sent from my BlackBerry® 
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri,
Consultant Physician,Mumbai, India.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Everywhere I go I find that a poet has
been there before me..(Sigmund Freud)
---------------------------------------------------------------------

Sunday, May 1, 2011

MAIL FROM OBLIVION

Sharing with you thoughts caught in the morning wind, blowing in from a horizon, blurred and long forgotten, to oblivion. It doesn't matter from whom, because I feel the presence of somebody without a face, with no name. And the faceless and the nameless never mattered...
The morning, whose shine and glory got blown into a thousand moments that shall never pass, by the morbid despair I feel in the wind, tells me that this faceless voice without a name could be somebody from us.. or maybe not.. maybe one who used to be, but isn't any more.

Draw your own conclusion, if at all..
-- -- --- ---- ---- ---- --- -- -- -- --- ---- ---- ---- --- --
-- -- --- ---- ---- ---- --- -- -- -- --- ---- ---- ---- --- --
To
............,
............


Utterly Disillusioned... I don't see Hope anywhere ahead. Our collective consciousness as Indians has been plagued, the malady of Corruption having eaten its way deep into our bones, so shamelessly deep that our scrupules, our ideas and beliefs around the Right or the Wrong have become essentially non-existent.

It is the corrupted mind of us, the Indian middle-class, that has conveniently allowed this to happen without any reaction. We have become so used to short-cuts and the short term pleasures for which we have bartered away our self-respect, that we have forgotten how to react. And thus we continue to exist as pathetic empty souls devoid of any substance that one can take pride in. We are non-entities which do not demand answers from within us any more, in times when we find ourselves in confrontation with moments of bitter truth.

So we, existentially bankrupt, just keep on running from our own conscience that we smother to silence every day without any guilt, and that which returns to haunt us again and again. And one can see a writing on the wall becoming clearer by the minute : everything we cheated ourselves of, shall return to haunt us..

--------- XYZ
---------------------------------------------------------------------
 Sent from my BlackBerry® 
Dr.Anirban Chaudhuri
Consultant Physician (special interest in
Cardiology & Critical Care)
Mumbai, India.
@ drchodri@yahoo.co.in
@ dranirbanchaudhuri@gmail.com
@ philodoc_2@hotmail.com
http://jogyou963.blogspot.com
http://anirbanspeak.blogspot.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Everywhere I go I find that a poet has
been there before me..(Sigmund Freud)
---------------------------------------------------------------------